Playing by the book

Reviews of kids' books and the crazy, fun stuff they inspire us to do

Cybils nominees: Three books by Atinuke

Posted on | November 1, 2011 | 16 Comments

Only one author has three books on the longlist for a Cybil Award in the the Early Chapter Book category and that is the Nigerian born, UK based Atinuke.

The No. 1 Car Spotter is set in an unnamed African village and follows a few months in the life of a young boy called Oluwalase Babatunde Benson, better known as No. 1.

In No. 1′s village no-one owns a car, but a road passes nearby and No. 1 and his grandpa spend so much of their time car-spotting that they can tell what car is approaching the village just by the sound its engine makes.

One day the village cart breaks, and so No. 1′s family is unable to take their goods to market. If the family cannot sell their palm oil, yams and mangoes there will be no money for pencils and shoes for school or kerosene for lamps.

As with the other tales from No. 1′s life in this book, ingenuity and community spirit combined with a good dose of humour come together in the solving of the problem of the broken cart. And whilst the precise nature of the situations No. 1 finds himself in may not be familiar to many young readers of The No. 1 Car Spotter (for example, what to do with wheelbarrows donated by an NGO), it is a testament to Atinuke’s storytelling skill that we are all drawn in and convincingly transported to No. 1′s village where it is simply a delight to be part of his extended family, full of love and care and laughter for the duration of our reading.

Good Luck, Anna Hibiscus and Have Fun, Anna Hibiscus are the 3rd and 4th books in a short series following the life of a young girl and her family who live in urban Africa (once again the precise location and country remain unnamed).

Good Luck Anna Hibiscus follows Anna and her family as they prepare for Anna’s impending trip to visit her grandmother in Canada for Christmas, whilst Have Fun Anna Hibiscus is all about Anna’s month in that snowy country, her first time abroad.

As with The No. 1 Car Spotter the short stories in each of these books have real heart at the centre of them. They are packed with unsentimental but fierce love, thoughtfulness and kindness, always mixed up with plenty to giggle about. All three books show us how lives and people can be different and yet fundamentally the same all around the world. For example the food Anna loves may not be known to many of the 6/7/8 year old readers in the UK and US (“Bean curd cooked in banana leaves… goat meat in a banana and onion stew“) but the enjoyment shared by all as they sit down to a family feast together crosses all national and cultural boundaries.

As a parent I loved these books because they have such heart and soul; at the end of reading each aloud I had a lump in my throat and tears in my eyes. They “teach” in that very best of ways a good book can – they opened our eyes to different ways of living, different ways of viewing the world all without preaching, judgement and without feeding stereotypes (for example it turns out that Anna Hibiscus is mixed race, and the Africa in both books is a modern one, where people text and send emails). Each of the three nominated books is brilliantly written with a magical mixture of humour, local colour, pace and drama.

As kids my children loved these books because “they are funny”, “they are about families like mine” (we’re a white family in suburban Britain so that tells you something about the universality in Atinuke’s storytelling), “they are interesting” (we’ve looked at maps, recipes and lots of cars as a result of these books) :-)

M and J playing "African Market" having enjoyed the stories of No. 1 and Anna Hibiscus

M, J and I all want to read more about No. 1 and Anna Hibiscus, a telling testament to these wonderful, prize-worthy books (fortunately there are more books in both series, already available at least in the UK). Do go and find/reserve copies today; the books are great read-alouds if you’re looking for something to read to several siblings of different ages and sexes together, and they’ll also be greatly enjoyed by curious, young, independent readers.

The only criticism I’ve seen in some reviews of Atinuke’s books is that they are set in a generalised “Africa”, and this might feed into the misconception addressed in the great picture book Africa is not a country. I personally did not find the vague setting of these stories a problem as all three of these stories seemed to me more about what unites people than what separates us, and in that spirit it didn’t seem important to know whether No. 1′s family lived in Sudan or South Africa, or whether Anna Hibiscus’s family home was in Lusaka or Luanda.

If I’m honest I do, however, have two problems with these books. (1) My copies came from the library but now I want my own copies for the family, and (2) Which book of the 3 would I propose win the Cybil in this category? Each is wonderful. Each has made me so glad we’ve read it in our family. Perhaps there’s a compete works of Anituke that could solve this problem? ;-)

Disclaimer: This review represents my own personal opinion and does not reflect discussions or decisions of the Cybils Easy Reader / Early Chapter Book Panel.

These book were originally published in the UK before being released in the US so they are widely available over here.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • Twitter

Comments

16 Responses to “Cybils nominees: Three books by Atinuke”

  1. Melissa @imaginationsoup
    November 1st, 2011 @ 1:26 am

    I agree – these books are wonderful and beautifully written!

  2. Zoe
    November 1st, 2011 @ 7:09 am

    Hi Melissa, I just hope round 1 judges send at least one through to round 2!

  3. Stacey
    November 1st, 2011 @ 9:43 am

    Zoe- I too love these books. Interestingly, I read the Anna Hibiscus that was nominated last year with my girls and they didn’t seem to like it. I have no idea why and will be anxious to try again!

  4. Zoe
    November 1st, 2011 @ 10:16 am

    Hi Stacey, I’m really interested in the fact that your girls didn’t enjoy them – both mine really loved all three stories (we read them aloud in bed together last week which was a holiday week here). If you ask them why (and they remember why!) do let me know what they say.

  5. se7en
    November 1st, 2011 @ 1:40 pm

    These books look fabulous – I am looking out for the #1 car spotter – for sure!!! That reflects so well on many local kids here, who spend their days perfecting the art of telling a car by its “sound.”

  6. Zoe
    November 1st, 2011 @ 7:56 pm

    Hi Se7en, If you do get hold of these books I’d love to know what you make of them – how these African stories are actually received by African families. As you can tell, I loved them!

  7. Ali B
    November 1st, 2011 @ 8:02 pm

    I *love* Atinuke. So important for both children of African heritage here in the UK to see themselves reflected in books, and also in our globalised society, as you say, to see what connects us as well as what separates us.

  8. Zoe
    November 1st, 2011 @ 8:48 pm

    Hi Ali, I’d love to hear Atinuke at a live storytelling event – have you ever seen her perform?

  9. Corinne Robson
    November 1st, 2011 @ 9:00 pm

    If any of your readers live on the other side of the pond so to speak and are close to Madison, WI, USA, Atinuke is one of the featured speakers at the International Children’s and Young Adult Literature Celebration “Open a Door… Open a Book…Open your Mind… to the World”. Takes place Nov 19th – here is the link http://www.wioc.wisc.edu/events/childlit/index.html

  10. Actually Mummy...
    November 2nd, 2011 @ 9:20 pm

    I have never heard of them so thank you. And I have only just found you (don’t know how that happened). Given that I am ‘a book-worm and a speed-reader’ I am going to have a good old trawl through your archives. I have a feeling Mummy is going to like it here!

  11. Zoe
    November 3rd, 2011 @ 12:45 pm

    Great to have you stop by Actually Mummy! Hope you find some more book recommendations that appeal to you here.

  12. Monica Edinger
    November 7th, 2011 @ 11:25 am

    Just to say I don’t find the setting vague at all — It feels distinctly West African to me based on my experiences in Sierra Leone. That is, it is not a generic “African” setting at all. I wrote a bit about this in my review because it seems such an unfortunate sticking point for some.

    While there are situations where I find people generalizing about Africa (I debated just that recently here: http://bit.ly/uGYKIy), that is not the case here. The author is clearly making an artistic decision to use the word “Africa” and I think it is lovely. Perhaps this is something you could ask her about when you interview her.

  13. Zoe
    November 7th, 2011 @ 1:17 pm

    Thanks Monica for stopping by. It’s great to hear from someone with recent experience of living in (West) Africa that Atinuke’s books ring true. I’ll let you know when the interview goes live.

  14. choxbox
    November 8th, 2011 @ 1:13 pm

    Thanks to your review I ordered book 1 and the 6-year old is absolutely hooked! Am now ordering the rest of the series.

    Also bought a copy of Astrosaurs last week, and thought of you :)

    So once again, THANKS ZOE!

  15. I Can Read Carnival + The Dragon Stone « Chapter Book of the Day
    November 15th, 2011 @ 1:42 pm

    [...] Playing by the Book joins the carnival with Three Books by Atinuke [...]

  16. Day 10: Atinuke «
    February 10th, 2012 @ 10:47 am

    [...] After a stint at boarding school, adventures in England, France, Germany and Spain, a bout of illness led Atinuke to write ANNA HIBISCUS. Atinuke’s nuanced tales, called “memorable and enchanting”, explore issues of class, family, and tradition with love; and they invite readers to explore “different ways of living, different ways of viewing the world all without preaching, judgemen… [...]

Leave a Reply





CommentLuv badge

  • Coming soon – new adventures

  • Categories